Your holidays are about to get extra festive. Rich molasses and warm gingerbread spices give this homemade toffee a seasonal twist. Put this gingerbread toffee on your holiday dessert table and you have a guaranteed crowd pleaser.

A stack of gingerbread toffee with gingerbread people ornaments and a small Christmas tree in the background.

Jump to:

Ingredients
How to Make Gingerbread Toffee
Do I Need a Candy Thermometer to Make Homemade Toffee?
Perfect Pairing
Feeling Festive? Try These Other Holiday Burrata and Bubbles Recipes.
📖 Recipe

Confession: I'm obsessed with gingerbread anything. Of all the Christmas characters, gingerbread people are the most adorable, and I not so secretly want to live in a real gingerbread house. Dream big, right?

I also love making toffee for the holidays, so before I made my first batch of the season, I thought, "Hey, what if I made a gingerbread version of this toffee?" I've always loved the Land O'Lakes classic toffee, so I took that recipe and swapped out some of the white sugar for molasses and dark brown sugar and added gingerbread spices and vanilla extract.

Voila! Just like that I had gingerbread toffee. I took the batch to my family's house for Thanksgiving and was both pleased and sad that it disappeared quickly --- pleased that everyone gobbled it up but sad because when I went to get a piece for myself, I discovered it was already gone.

Now I'm excited to bring this gingerbread toffee to you! I'm sure you'll love this gingerbread toffee as much as I do, so let's jump into it.

Related: For more Christmas desserts, check out my peppermint bark ice cream and gingerbread tiramisu.

Gingerbread toffee on a wooden board with red Christmas ornaments.

Ingredients

Before we start cooking, I always like to organize my ingredients to ensure everything is ready to go. Here’s what we need to make this gingerbread toffee.

Butter
White sugar
Dark brown sugar
Molasses
Light corn syrup
Water
Cinnamon
Ginger
Cloves
Vanilla extract
Chocolate chips
Pecans

An aerial view of gingerbread toffee scattered on a wooden board.

How to Make Gingerbread Toffee

Making your own candy may sound intimidating, but with a watchful eye and a basic candy thermometer, anyone can successfully make a batch of this gingerbread toffee. Let’s get started, shall we?

To start, we toast our pecans on the stove. This only takes a few minutes, and it gives our pecans a serious flavor boost. We set those aside and move on to the candy making process.

For our toffee, we throw all of our ingredients into a heavy-bottomed pot except the spices, nuts, vanilla extract and chocolate.

The gingerbread toffee ingredients in a pot about to cook.

Now we stir continuously until everything melts into a smooth mixture like this.

Cooking the gingerbread toffee mixture until it's smooth.

We keep cooking the mixture until it starts to bubble. Initially, only a portion of the mixture will bubble while the rest will remain smooth.

The gingerbread toffee mixture as it's beginning to boil in some parts.

But keep cooking and the entire mixture will eventually thicken and turn into a roiling boil like so.

The gingerbread toffee after it's come to a roiling boil and has darkened and reduced.

Once the mixture hits 300 degrees on a candy thermometer, we remove it from the heat and stir in a portion of the pecans, vanilla extract and spices. Now we pour the mixture onto a parchment paper-lined baking sheet. Be careful when you do this. We're working with a 300-degree mixture here, so we don't want any burned fingers.

Pouring the gingerbread toffee mixture onto parchment paper.

We then top the toffee with chocolate chips. The toffee will still be plenty hot, so the chocolate chips will begin to melt. To help with the process, we use a spoon to smooth the chocolate. Once the chocolate is perfectly smooth, we top with the remaining pecans.

Smoothing the chocolate chips onto the gingerbread toffee.

Sprinkling the chopped pecans onto the gingerbread toffee.

As delicious as it looks, we need to find patience within ourselves and let the toffee sit until it cools and the chocolate sets. Expect for this to take at least three hours, though you can speed the process by placing the toffee in the refrigerator.

I know. Being an impatient person, I'm well-aware that waiting is the worst. But it is necessary here. Sigh.

Once the toffee finally cools and the chocolate sets, we're ready to break our gingerbread toffee into pieces and enjoy our festive holiday candy. Isn't this time of year the best?

Do I Need a Candy Thermometer to Make Homemade Toffee?

I highly recommend a candy thermometer when making homemade toffee. When I make caramel sauce, judging the sauce by its color is simple, but candy making takes more precise temperature monitoring to get the candy to the proper stage.

Some people cook candy with a water test. With this method, you drop bit of the candy syrup into water to see what shape the syrup takes. I find this method to be a pain, and if you cook the candy syrup at too high a temperature, you’ll be left with a ruined batch of toffee. A candy thermometer is a much safer bet.

Besides, most candy thermometers are cheap, and then you’ll have it for proper deep frying, which means you can make my oh-so delicious pumpkin crullers with caramelized maple glaze. Lucky you. Plus, with Amazon, you can get a candy thermometer in no time if you feel too lazy to make it to the store.

Gingerbread toffee on a wooden board with a red and white rustic string.

Perfect Pairing

For a beer, look no further than a Belgian quad. With a Belgian quad, you get lots of dried fruit and caramel-like malt notes that work beautifully with the gingerbread spices and caramelized sugar of the toffee.

If the mood for wine strikes, I'm always a fan of a tawny port with gingerbread-flavored treats and toffee. Considering that we're bringing the two together in this dessert, it only make sense to keep the tawny port pairing going. A tawny port has a lot of the same flavor qualities as a Belgian quad, so it goes just as well with this gingerbread toffee.

For your next holiday party, I hope you try this gingerbread toffee. I'm sure this candy will disappear as quickly as it did with my family. Please let me know how you enjoyed this gingerbread toffee recipe in the comment section and don’t forget to sign up for my newsletter. You can also catch me on Instagram, Pinterest, Facebook and Twitter.

Cheers!

Gingerbread Toffee

Ingredients

How to Make Gingerbread Toffee

Do I Need a Candy Thermometer to Make Homemade Toffee?

Perfect Pairing

Feeling Festive? Try These Other Holiday Burrata and Bubbles Recipes.

📖 Recipe