Coconut Margarita

Jump to Recipe

If you want to pretend you're on a tropical escape, do yourself a favor and whip up this sweet and tart coconut margarita! Made with cream of coconut and fresh lime juice, this is one margarita full of tropical flavor. With just one sip, this fruity coconut margarita will trick you into thinking you're sipping refreshing cocktails on a beach getaway.

A coconut margarita with a yellow napkin and lime slices on the side with toasted coconut scattered around it.

Jump to:

Why You'll Love This Recipe
Ingredients
Step-by-Step Instructions
How to Make a Pitcher of Coconut Margaritas
Recipe FAQs
Variations and Substitutions
Expert Tips for Making the Best Margaritas
Perfect Pairing
Enjoy More Margaritas
📖 Recipe

Why You'll Love This Recipe

A tropical take on a classic: I love a classic margarita. In fact, I strongly believe everyone should have a go-to classic margarita recipe that ditches the mix and uses only tequila, orange liqueur, fresh lime juice and a touch of simple syrup if desired.

While it's important to have that baseline for a proper margarita, let's make our hearts happy and have some fun with flavored margaritas. So without further ado, I present this coconut margarita recipe!

Perfect for pool sipping and any outdoor party: If you're somewhere tropical or by a pool, I wouldn't blame you for trying to drink your weight in pina coladas — a noble goal. But why stop at pina coladas? Coconut margaritas bring that same tropical vibe, but served on the rocks, they're not as heavy, which makes them great for pool sipping.

Quick and easy: These tropical margaritas are super easy to whip up. They only require a few ingredients, and you can have this refreshing beach cocktail in hand in under five minutes.

Related: If you can't get enough tropical margarita recipes, you'll also love my pina colada margarita and passion fruit margarita.

Ingredients

Tequila: I've made this recipe with both reposado tequila and blanco tequila. While you can certainly use either variety, I prefer reposado. This type of tequila ages in oak barrels from anywhere from two to 12 months, which gives it a more nuanced flavor with hints of vanilla. Blanco, also known as white or silver tequila, goes straight into stainless barrels, so we don't get those delicious aging notes.

Cream of coconut: I took the Pepsi Challenge and made these margaritas with both coconut milk and cream of coconut to see how the ingredients compared. Matt and I agreed that cream of coconut was the winner.

Now, the coconut milk was still enjoyable. We certainly finished our drinks without a problem, but the strong coconut flavor wasn't as prominent. Cream of coconut is also one of the classic ingredients in a pina colada, so it gave that exact sweetness I was craving.

Orange liqueur: For a top-shelf margarita, I love Cointreau or Grand Marnier. Triple sec also works well.

Lime juice: Make sure you use freshly squeezed lime juice. The bottled juice is not nearly as bright tasting. The best margaritas absolutely call for fresh juice.

Step-by-Step Instructions

Make the Toasted Coconut Rim

Step 1: For a fun toasted coconut rim, we pour some honey or agave nectar on a small plate and add toasted coconut to another plate. We then dip the rim of the glass in the honey and then swirl it in the toasted coconut flakes (photo 1).

Swirling the glass in toasted coconut on a small white plate.

Mix the Margarita

Step 2: Now we add our cream of coconut, tequila, lime juice and orange liqueur to a cocktail shaker (photo 2) and toss in a handful of ice cubes into the mixture.

Pouring cream of coconut into a clear crystal cocktail shaker on a wooden board.

Step 3: We put on the cocktail shaker top and vigorously shake for 15-30 seconds (photo 3).

Shaking the margarita with two hands against a wooden board surface.

Strain, Garnish and Serve

Step 4: All that's left is to strain our delicious coconut beverage into our glass and garnish with a fresh lime wedge.

Straining the margarita into a glass with a coconut rim.

Find a spot on the patio, give it a taste and enjoy those tropical vibes! Delicious, isn't it?

Bonus: For more beachy cocktails, you'll also love my passion fruit martini, Painkiller cocktail and mango mojito.

How to Make a Pitcher of Coconut Margaritas

For your next summer party, you need a pitcher of coconut margaritas ready to go. Here's how to do it.

Simply stir together the tequila, cream of coconut, lime juice and orange liqueur in a large pitcher.
Cover and refrigerate for up to 24 hours. After that, the lime juice starts to lose its brightness.
Stir before stirring since the cream of coconut will settle on the bottom of the pitcher.
While guests can serve themselves from the pitcher, I recommend still shaking each drink. Not only does this better incorporate the thick cream of coconut but it adds the necessary dilution, and it aerates the drink for a nicer texture.

You can find the exact proportions for a pitcher in the notes section of the recipe card.

Recipe FAQs

How do you toast coconut for the rim?

To toast coconut, we add a handful of flakes to a non-stick skillet and turn the heat to medium. We then let the heat work its magic, and the coconut will start to brown after a few minutes. Make sure you periodically shake the pan to keep the coconut from burning. You'll know it's done when it turns fragrant, and some flakes will turn brown.

What if I only have coconut milk instead of cream of coconut?

Although I highly recommend using cream of coconut for this recipe, you technically could use canned coconut milk with 1 ounce of simple syrup. Make sure you shake the canned coconut milk well before using. I do not recommend the refrigerated type of coconut milk that is sold near the dairy alternatives.

How do you choose the best tequila for margaritas?

Look for the best 100% agave tequila that fits your budget. Don't feel like you have to spend a fortunate. A mid-range tequila is perfectly fine.

I'm especially partial to Corralejo, and we always keep a bottle on hand — it's silky smooth at a great price point.

Can you adjust this recipe to make a frozen coconut margarita?

Absolutely. Instead of shaking the ingredients in a cocktail shaker, we add them to a blender with ½-1 cup crushed ice and blend until smooth.

Rather than cubed ice, I definitely recommend crushed ice. It blends much easier to give you a smoother texture.

Can you make this into a mocktail margarita?

Sure, simply substitute the regular tequila for a zero-proof tequila. These days, we have so many more nonalcoholic spirit options, and it's a great way to still enjoy margaritas without the kick.

A coconut margarita with a yellow and white napkin to the right and a plate of coconut behind it.

Variations and Substitutions

While I've made this margarita so many times and find it perfect as is, you can absolutely put your own spin on it. Here are a few suggestions.

Give it a spicy kick: Muddle a couple jalapeño slices with the cream of coconut before mixing or use Tajin on the rim.

Add an extra fruity twist: To add a strawberry flavor, for instance, you can muddle some fresh strawberries before mixing.

Use another spirit: Not a big tequila fan? Try this with rum or vodka — I bet you'll love the results.

Expert Tips for Making the Best Margaritas

Make sure you use cream of coconut, not coconut cream: They are very different products. You can generally find cream of coconut near the cocktail mixers, and it comes in either a can or squeeze bottle.

Grab limes that have some give when you squeeze them: If the limes are hard, they're dried out.

Before juicing the lime, firmly roll it on the countertop under the palm of your hand: This helps get the juices flowing.

Adjust sweetness to your taste: Given that I was going for that kind of sweetness you get in a pina colada, I used 3 ounces of cream of coconut. If you don't like your drinks sweet, you may want to tone down the cream of coconut to 1 ounce. But if you're like me and dig pina coladas, 3 ounces should be just right.

Perfect Pairing

My tropical pico de gallo with mango, papaya, toasted coconut and fresh ginger is an obvious choice with this coconut margarita. You also love my lobster tacos with mango-habanero salsa with this summery sipper.

If you’re craving dessert, my strawberry mojito sorbet is a delicious pairing. You could even throw a scoop of sorbet into your coconut margarita for a fun adult float. And who doesn't love fun adult floats? And, of course, my spiced orange tres leches is the perfect sweet end to a margarita night.

Let’s take advantage of this summer weather and make a batch of these coconut margaritas for your next patio dinner. This coconut margarita is everything I love in a summer cocktail, and I hope you love it too.

Cheers!

A hand grabbing a coconut margarita with toasted coconut around it.

Enjoy More Margaritas

If you love this recipe, please leave a comment with a five-star rating — or simply hit the five-star button in the recipe card. Don't forget to sign up for my newsletter, and you can follow me on Facebook, Instagram, Pinterest and TikTok.

📖 Recipe

Comments

5 from 213 votes (187 ratings without comment)

Coconut Margarita

Why You'll Love This Recipe

Ingredients